Art and Architecture Critic

James Gardner

55 articles 2009–2018

James Gardner is an art and architecture critic who contributed regularly to The Weekly Standard from 2009 to 2018. His writing for the magazine covered visual arts, exhibitions, urban design, and cultural commentary, with pieces on gallery shows, biennials, and the built environment. He is also known for his broader work as a cultural critic and author.

The First Modernist

October 7, 2018 · Books & Arts, Art, The Met

James Gardner on Delacroix’s undeserved reputation for greatness.

Fraught Figures

July 22, 2018 · Books & Arts, Art, painting

James Gardner on the surprising resilience of Giacometti’s spindly statues.

Versailles for Sore Eyes

May 25, 2018 · Versailles, France, Louis XIV

The art and architecture (and tourist souvenirs) of the Sun King’s palace.

The Course of Thomas Cole

March 23, 2018 · James Gardner, Books and Art, Art Gallery

One of the reasons most art writing is not worth reading—and there are several reasons—is the irritating habit of critics of personalizing their subject and making it all about themselves. It goes without saying that this tendency is to be strenuously resisted, if not punished, but I am about to…

Face and Fame

January 6, 2018 · James Gardner, Books and Art, Table of Contents

In the sundry debates about the Western canon that periodically vex our culture, attention is always focused on those who have been excluded from it, with the implicit assumption that some malign force is behind that omission. Far less discussed but no less important is the question of who has…

Michelangelo, the Master of Motion

November 24, 2017 · James Gardner, Books and Art, Art

It would be hard to invent a more pallid or inadequate title than Michelangelo: Divine Draftsman and Designer for the exhibition that has just opened at the Metropolitan Museum of Art. Divinity, of course, is always an asset and Michelangelo is a name to conjure with. But neither of the words that…

The Childlike Joy of Alexander Calder

October 10, 2017 · magazine_repost, James Gardner, Books and Art

In the past 100 years, no visual artist has contributed more to the sum total of human happiness than Alexander Calder. If you think about it, this generating of happiness, to the extent to which it retains any cultural prestige these days, is seen as the domain of musicians and writers far more…

Getting Things Moving

October 6, 2017 · James Gardner, Books and Art, children

In the past 100 years, no visual artist has contributed more to the sum total of human happiness than Alexander Calder. If you think about it, this generating of happiness, to the extent to which it retains any cultural prestige these days, is seen as the domain of musicians and writers far more…

Rebel's Reward

August 9, 2017 · magazine_repost, James Gardner, Galactic Empire

If an award were given for winning awards, it would surely go, by acclamation and universal consent, to Robert Rauschenberg, the most beribboned figure in the history of art. Not only did he win almost every award you can think of, but others were invented so that he could win those as well. Had…

Rebel's Reward

August 4, 2017 · James Gardner, Books and Art, Galactic Empire

If an award were given for winning awards, it would surely go, by acclamation and universal consent, to Robert Rauschenberg, the most beribboned figure in the history of art. Not only did he win almost every award you can think of, but others were invented so that he could win those as well. Had…

Glamour Shots

July 14, 2017 · James Gardner, Books and Art, Art Gallery

New York

Empathetic Eye: The Art of George W. Bush

June 25, 2017 · James Gardner, magazine_repost, Books and Art

George W. Bush has been painting for several years now, but has only recently become an artist. His first paintings, mostly of world leaders, were remarkably well received, even by an art establishment that had hardly been friendly to his administration. And yet, although those early paintings were…

Empathetic Eye

June 23, 2017 · James Gardner, Books and Art, Table of Contents

George W. Bush has been painting for several years now, but has only recently become an artist. His first paintings, mostly of world leaders, were remarkably well received, even by an art establishment that had hardly been friendly to his administration. And yet, although those early paintings were…

Of Saints and Vandals

January 6, 2017 · James Gardner, Art, Museums

Whatever Gary Vikan, former director of the Walters Museum in Baltimore, thinks of the larger world, he has a somewhat jaundiced view of the art world itself, or at least that corner of it that forms his main area of expertise, medieval and Byzantine art. And the impression we are left with from…

The Art of War

September 2, 2016 · James Gardner, Military, Magazine

New York

Modern Precision

August 5, 2016 · James Gardner, Magazine, Books and Arts

As Americans, we take Stuart Davis for granted. Although he has achieved a certain canonic status, in practice that means little more than that we no longer feel that we really need to look at him. It takes an exhibition like the Whitney's "Stuart Davis: In Full Swing" to see, with redoubled force,…

Expressions of Joy

June 17, 2016 · James Gardner, Greece, Magazine

Few cultural experiences can match that moment when, for the first time, you approach the great Pergamon Altar in Berlin. Because it is famous, but not as famous as the Ara Pacis or the Elgin Marbles, many visitors will encounter it in complete ignorance that something so big or so imposing has…

Picasso’s Avocation

November 16, 2015 · James Gardner, Magazine, Books and Arts

In recent years, the Museum of Modern Art has seemed to have a target splattered across its ever-expanding façade—and not the artsy sort of target depicted by Jasper Johns. From all corners of the art world, critics have shown up with their BB guns, which they mistook for bazookas, and aimed them…

Rocks of Ages

July 27, 2015 · James Gardner, book reviews, Magazine

Isamu Noguchi (1904-1988) appeared before the world as a two-form, shape-shifting paradox. One is hard put to say if he was an American sculptor of Japanese extraction, or a Japanese sculptor who happened to spend most of his life in the United States. The short answer, according to Hayden…

Museum With a View

June 3, 2015 · James Gardner, Arts, Architecture

Renzo Piano is too good an architect for his new Whitney Museum, in Manhattan’s meatpacking district, to be a total failure. The interior is, in general, quite good and surely a vast improvement over Marcel Breuer’s nuclear bunker on Madison Avenue, which housed the museum for half-a-century. And…

A Practiced Eye

March 30, 2015 · James Gardner, Magazine, Books and Arts

Piero di Cosimo was, in all likelihood, the strangest painter of the 15th century. “Men could perceive the strangeness of his brain,” wrote his biographer, Giorgio Vasari. “He knew no pleasure save that of going off by himself with his thoughts, letting his fancy roam, and building castles in air.…

Only Yesterday

February 9, 2015 · James Gardner, Arts, Magazine

Are we allowed, in 2015, to like Thomas Hart Benton? And if so, are we allowed to admit in public that we like him? 

A Visual Dialogue

December 8, 2014 · James Gardner, book reviews, Magazine

Few books of late have pleased me as much as this one. Whether it will interest anyone else is an open question, but it might, and it should. In essence, this book consists of an ongoing dialogue between two very cultured men, Philippe de Montebello, former director of the Metropolitan Museum of…

Eager to Please

September 22, 2014 · James Gardner, Magazine, Books and Arts

In theory, this Jeff Koons retrospective is a big deal. It has taken over the entire Marcel Breuer fortress at 945 Madison Avenue—an honor that, if memory serves, has been accorded to no previous artist. Perhaps more important, it is the last exhibition that the Whitney will ever mount in the…

Canvas Battlefield

August 19, 2013 · James Gardner, Magazine, Books and Arts

In one of his bolder poetic flourishes, General MacArthur once invoked “the sputter of musketry” to refer to burp guns and bazookas. His phrase had the élan of gallantry, even chivalry, to it, as it deftly sidestepped the new and very different realities of modern warfare. Some generations earlier,…

Happy the Man

November 19, 2012 · James Gardner, Magazine, Books and Arts

 

Installed for Good

October 1, 2012 · James Gardner, culture, Japan

Though every generation dutifully brings forth its crop of visual artists, some harvests are more blessed and bounteous than others. And while few have been as sparse as those of recent date, we can all take some consolation in the Whitney’s retrospective of Yayoi Kusama. Any age that engendered…

Fad Men

May 7, 2012 · James Gardner, Magazine, Books and Arts

Paradox is supposed to be interesting and subversion is supposed to be fun. But this year’s supposedly subversive Whitney Biennial, though paradox incarnate, is the sort of thing that gives soul-annihilating ennui a bad name. And its tedium is a direct consequence of the paradox at its very heart:…

Jobs Creation

September 5, 2011 · James Gardner, Silicon Valley, Steve Jobs

There was something almost princely in the way Steve Jobs went about selecting the shape and location of the proposed new Apple headquarters, announced in June to the city council of Cupertino, California, in Silicon Valley. Usually a large project like this—even a small project—develops gradually…

Cities of Dreams

June 13, 2011 · James Gardner, Arts, Magazine

Most sophisticated museumgoers would think it ineffably crass to complain about Cezanne’s unending sequence of apples and peaches, or the relentless quadrilaterals of Piet Mondrian. But it appears that certain of these people are no proof against the ennui that sets in when they encounter yet…

Maxxi-mum Exposure

May 30, 2011 · James Gardner, Magazine, Books and Arts

Even visitors who know Rome well are unlikely to venture north along the Via Flaminia, beyond the Aurelian Walls that encircle most of the city. Compared with what lies inside the walls, and with a few exceptions beyond, there is little to see in this clean and barren part of town. Though the…

Atlantic Crossing

March 7, 2011 · James Gardner, Arts, Magazine

Modern Life Edward Hopper and His Time Whitney Museum of American Art Through April 10

An Idea of Order

December 27, 2010 · James Gardner, Magazine, Books and Arts

Chaos & Classicism

Castelli’s Art

August 23, 2010 · James Gardner, Magazine, Books and Arts

Leo and His Circle

Biennial Bland

May 10, 2010 · James Gardner, Magazine, Books and Arts

At this late date in the history of  Western civilization, bashing the Whitney Biennial is such an inveterate habit among art critics that even to acknowledge the fact, as I have just done, has become a cliché. Indeed, this reflex is so entrenched by now that, in what may be the single greatest act…

Biblionline

February 8, 2010 · James Gardner, Magazine, Books and Arts

For a time there, it looked as if e-readers would be a dismal, faddish flop. It was hard to argue with the preliminary assessment of Steve Jobs: “It doesn’t matter how good or bad the product is, the fact is that people don’t read anymore. Forty percent of the people in the U.S. read one book or…

Late Mastery

January 4, 2010 · James Gardner, Magazine, Books and Arts

Kandinsky

Exile's Voice

June 15, 2009 · James Gardner, Magazine, Books and Arts

George Steiner at 'The New Yorker'

Rembrandt Lite

April 6, 2009 · James Gardner, Magazine, Books and Arts

Jan Lievens