Legal and Policy Commentator

David Wagner

9 articles 2005–2018

David Wagner is a writer and legal commentator who contributed to The Weekly Standard between 2005 and 2018. His articles for the magazine frequently focused on constitutional law, judicial decision-making, and social policy debates, including issues surrounding same-sex marriage and judicial reasoning.

Who Loves a Jury?

January 20, 2014 · Magazine, David M. Wagner, Constitution

As an institution, the jury—especially in civil cases—is having a bad run these days. Nobody likes that summons in the mail (even though clerks-of-court in the electronic era have figured out ways to make jury service less of a hassle). Experts who monitor medical-legal issues scoff at the notion…

Over to You, California

October 8, 2007 · Magazine, David M. Wagner

On September 18, in Conaway v. Deane, Maryland became the latest in a string of non-Bible Belt states whose high courts have declined to impose recognition of same-sex marriages.

Gay Marriage Lite

November 6, 2006 · Magazine, David M. Wagner

IF NOT NEW JERSEY, then (besides Massachusetts) where? A liberal state with no explicit prohibition on same-sex marriage in state law, and no law barring state officials from performing such marriages for out-of-staters--New Jersey would seem the perfect state in which to persuade the highest court…

California, Too!

October 23, 2006 · Magazine, David M. Wagner

THE FUTURE ain't what it used to be. You can't count on the inevitable any more. When the highest court in Massachusetts announced on November 18, 2003, that a right to same-sex marriage was contained in the Bay State's 226-year-old constitution, it seemed as if that court's self-concept--boldly…

Finally Some Rational Judges

July 24, 2006 · Magazine, David M. Wagner

ON JUNE 6, when the highest state court in New York dealt a setback to same-sex marriage, editorialists de nounced it as being "on the wrong side of history." These editorials protest too much: Their invocation of historical inevi tability suggests that this very factor is no longer to be counted…

Alito and "Rational Basis"

November 1, 2005 · David M. Wagner, Blog

INEVITABLY, liberal angst over the nomination of Judge Samuel Alito has focused on his vote to uphold the entire abortion statute at issue in Planned Parenthood v. Casey, including the spousal notification provision, which was the only part struck down by the rest of the Third Circuit, and later,…

Toss Away the Left's Schedule Sheet

July 8, 2005 · David M. Wagner, Blog

IN 1987, the Reagan administration seriously underestimated the energy and ruthlessness that its opponents would be willing to bring to bear against a Supreme Court nominee.

Beyond "Strange New Respect"

March 14, 2005 · Magazine, David M. Wagner

A NEW VARIATION ON THE "strange new respect" award is needed--in fact, is being developed--for Supreme Court Justice Anthony Kennedy. The worst of Ronald Reagan's appointees to the Court, Kennedy delivered the 5-4 decision on March 1 in Roper v. Simmons, holding that killers who kill before they…