Articles 2004 September

September 2004

163 articles

Kerry, Iraq, and the New York Review of Books

BURIED IN THE SECOND SENTENCE of the seventh paragraph of a 2,119 word story in Sunday's New York Times was the first sign that John Kerry has a prescriptive plan for Iraq. It wasn't easy to find. Ostensibly an article on Kerry's decision-making process, "Kerry as the Boss: Always More Questions"…

Matthew Continetti · Sep 30

The 51st State and the 2nd Amendment

YESTERDAY at 2:58 p.m. the House of Representatives passed the "District of Columbia Personal Protection Act." Floor debate was stunning, often managing to simultaneously defy the rules of logic and of constitutional law.

Katherine ManguWard · Sep 30

Don't Book to Havana

ANOTHER CONGRESSIONAL CUBA DEBATE. Another mini-breach among House Republicans. It's nothing new, but the latest flare-up comes at an inopportune moment for George W. Bush.

Duncan Currie · Sep 30

On Notice

IT STARTED on the Late, Late Show Monday night. Drudge posted a link to a picture of John Kerry's suddenly orange face on Tuesday, and Blogs for Bush, Blogs of War, and Best of the Web started an Oompa Loompa meme Tuesday afternoon. I played the Oompa Loompa song a few times during the afternoon…

Hugh Hewitt · Sep 30

The Great Firewall of China

"WE BELIEVE a well functioning society should have abundant, free and unbiased access to high quality information. Google therefore has a responsibility to the world," co-founder Larry Page declared earlier this year in the company's letter to prospective shareholders. But is Google all that…

Michael Boyer · Sep 30

The Bushes Do Dr. Phil

THE PRESIDENT and first lady appeared on Dr. Phil today in an interview that was recorded in June. Dr. Phil's wife joined him for the living room heart-to-heart, in which the first couple discussed parenting and home life.

David Skinner · Sep 29

When Was He For It (Before He Was Against It)?

ON TODAY'S Good Morning America, John Kerry defended his "I actually did vote for the $87 billion, before I voted against it," comment: "It just was a very inarticulate way of saying something, and I had one of those inarticulate moments late in the evening when I was dead tired in the primaries…

William Kristol · Sep 29

Blair Makes the Case

AS PRESIDENT BUSH prepares for Thursday night's debate, he might want to take a minute to read the remarks on Iraq and the war on terror by his ally Tony Blair, in his annual speech Tuesday at the Labour party's annual conference in Brighton:

William Kristol · Sep 29

Inconvenient Facts

THE BUSH ADMINISTRATION argues that the Iraq war was the central front in the war on terror. Not long ago, John Kerry agreed. He called Saddam Hussein a terrorist. He worried about Iraq passing weapons to terrorists. His running mate prominently cited Iraq's terrorist connections as a chief reason…

Stephen F. Hayes · Sep 29

The Real Grover Norquist

ON SEPTEMBER 12, the Spanish newspaper El Mundo published a wide-ranging interview with Grover Norquist, the president of Americans for Tax Reform, prominent conservative activist, and Karl Rove ally. It was a long interview, presented in a traditional Q & A format. You can go to El Mundo's…

Matthew Continetti · Sep 28

Surge Protector

A SURE BET in this campaign is that the media will write a big October comeback story for John Kerry. It is evitable for three reasons. First, the media works in a pack that is happiest when following a simple narrative. Second, from moribund to miracle campaigner is Kerry's tiresome myth turned…

Mike Murphy · Sep 28

Remembrance of Contracts Past

YESTERDAY, September 27, marked the ten-year anniversary of the historic signing of the Contract with America on the steps of the U.S. Capitol. And this fall marks the tenth anniversary of the subsequent (some would say consequent) election of a Republican majority in Congress. So far the…

David Skinner · Sep 28

Sprinting with Blinders On

EARLY LAST WEEK a select group was invited to George Soros's posh New York apartment to witness a debate between Richard Holbrooke, assistant secretary of State in the Clinton administration and a leading candidate for the top State Department job in a Kerry administration, and Bill Kristol, editor…

Irwin M. Stelzer · Sep 28

The Kerry-Kennedy Line

IN A SPEECH Monday at George Washington University, Senator Ted Kennedy accused the president of conducting an Iraq policy that has made it more likely that al Qaeda could launch a "nuclear 9/11." According to Kennedy, American military resources were needlessly diverted to the war in Iraq rather…

Daniel McKivergan · Sep 28

Another War He Didn't Like

AMONG DEMOCRATS, it is fashionable to remember the Cold War as a bipartisan effort. "Until the fall of the Berlin Wall in 1989," former senator Bill Bradley has said, "we were sure about one thing: We knew where we stood on foreign policy." The world was simple, according to President Clinton's…

Duncan Currie · Sep 27

Diversity Dropouts

LAST MARCH, when the University of Georgia decided to revive race in the admissions process, the Atlanta Journal-Constitution hailed the move as sound education policy. "Diversity holds rewards for all students," the editors assured their readers. Set aside talk about remedies for past…

Mark Bauerlein · Sep 27

Letter from Bedlam

THIS MORNING, out for my regular constitutional, I was called Adolf and accused of being a Nazi by a man with long orangish hair carrying a purse. I saw him coming down the block, and I nodded to him, for he had turned up some months ago at a book promotion talk I gave at a nearby Borders. During…

Joseph Epstein · Sep 27

Prairie Politics

LAST YEAR--on August 16, 2003, speeding in a borrowed white Cadillac down one of those long, dusty South Dakota highways that glide across the plains like endless ribbons--a Republican congressman named Bill Janklow ran a stop sign at 70 miles per hour and killed a passing motorcyclist.

Joseph Bottum · Sep 27

Rewriting the Koran

THE UNITED STATES took the bold step last week of formally designating Saudi Arabia a "country of particular concern" for its lack of religious freedom. In the words of the State Department's 2004 report on religious freedom worldwide, "basic religious freedoms are denied to all [Saudi citizens]…

Stephen Schwartz · Sep 27

Swinging Right

WHERE HAVE ALL the swing voters gone? The conventional answer is that the nation has become politically polarized and swing voters have taken sides. There's some truth in this, but there's a better explanation. In disproportionate numbers, swing voters have become Republicans over the past three…

Fred Barnes · Sep 27

The End of Gitmo Limbo

THE LEGAL LIMBO of the prisoners at Guantanamo is coming to an end. Spurred by the scandalous revelations from Abu Ghraib in late April and three Supreme Court decisions in late June, the administration is belatedly putting in place several layers of due process intended to ensure that the 585…

Thomas Powers · Sep 27

Trigger Happy

SOMETHING HAPPENED last week that sent reporters across the country scurrying for the nearest gun shop. A ban on certain assault weapons, signed into law by President Clinton in 1994, expired on Monday.

Katherine ManguWard · Sep 27

Unfortunate Democrats

IN 1969, THE CALIFORNIA rock musician John Fogerty wrote a song called "Fortunate Son," recorded it with his band, Creedence Clearwater Revival, and released it on the album Willy and the Poor Boys. It is a short song, lasting just over two minutes, and it is an intense one. "Some folks are born,…

Matthew Continetti · Sep 27

Victory or Surrender

LAST WEEK was the week the Kerry campaign, facing the increasingly likely prospect of its own electoral defeat, embraced the prospect of defeat in Iraq. Once upon a time, it seemed possible that a Democratic presidential candidate might (plausibly) charge the Bush administration with errors in its…

William Kristol · Sep 27

What Blogs Have Wrought

IF YOU TRAWL the posting boards at FreeRepublic.com long enough, you'll go mad. Hundreds of voices are shouting, spitting, and clamoring for attention at any given moment. The night of Wednesday September 8 was no different. Following the 8 P.M. airing of CBS's 60 Minutes hit on President Bush's…

Jonathan V. Last · Sep 27

Hurricane in a Teapot

LAST WEEKEND, Florida was swarming with FEMA workers, insurance adjusters, and pollsters. And all three groups agree--it's a mess down there.

Katherine ManguWard · Sep 27

The Big Mahatma

Sidebars Laurence H. Tribe's God Save This Honorable Court (1985), p. 83: Taft publicly pronounced Pitney to be a "weak member" of the Court to whom he could "not assign cases." Henry J. Abraham's Justices and Presidents (1974), p. 164: Taft publicly pronounced Pitney to be a "weak member" of the…

Joseph Bottum · Sep 24

The Worst of Cat Stevens

EARLIER THIS WEEK, I commented that, as Yusuf Islam, the singer Cat Stevens has held to an extreme Islamic fundamentalist position regarding music. I wrote, "Wahhabism, the state religion in Saudi Arabia, and the inspirer of al Qaeda, is especially known for its hatred of music. In Wahhabi…

Stephen Schwartz · Sep 24

Iraq is Not Vietnam, It's Guadalcanal

PUNDITS THESE DAYS are quick to compare the fighting in Iraq with the American loss in Vietnam 30 years ago. Terms like "quagmire" evoke the Southeast Asian jungle, where America's technological advantages were negated and committed Vietnamese guerrillas wore down the U.S. will to fight.

Powl Smith · Sep 24

Photographs Do Lie

PHOTOJOURNALIST Eddie Adams died last Sunday at age 71, but his place in history is secure. Indeed, Adams made history with his famous picture of South Vietnamese General Nguyen Ngoc Loan. Taken in Saigon on February 1, 1968, the picture showed Gen. Loan's point-blank execution of a Viet Cong…

Duncan Currie · Sep 24

Kerry and the Other "F"-word

JOHN KERRY'S NEW POLICY on Iraq is like a doughnut. It has a big hole in the middle. The Kerry four-point plan calls for recruiting more allies to help in Iraq, accelerating the training of Iraqi soldiers, pushing ahead on reconstruction, and guaranteeing a national election by next January. All…

Fred Barnes · Sep 23

End the Genocide Now

SELDOM HAS THE GULF between diplomatic talk and effective action been as stark as it was this week at the United Nations. On Tuesday, President Bush, speaking before the U.N. General Assembly, called on the Sudanese government to stop the killing in Darfur, reiterating Secretary of State Colin…

William Kristol · Sep 23

Ghosting for Les

ON TUESDAY, CBS president Les Moonves told the Los Angeles Times that it was "clear that something went seriously wrong with the process" that produced DanScam. That's like The Zepplin Company announcing that the Hindenburg had a little trouble landing in New Jersey.

Hugh Hewitt · Sep 23

Is Cat Stevens a Terrorist?

ON TUESDAY, U.S. authorities diverted a United Airlines London-Washington flight to Bangor, Maine, where the ex-pop singer formerly known as Cat Stevens, now as Yusuf Islam, was questioned by federal security agents, and then ordered deported back to Britain. Yusuf Islam, it turns out, is on the…

Stephen Schwartz · Sep 22

Kerry's Phony Foreign Forces

ON MONDAY, in Brussels, Republican strategist Charles Black debated Kerry campaign adviser and fundraiser R. Scott Pastrick on the implications for Europe of the upcoming U.S. presidential elections. As reported from Europe, Pastrick stated that a Kerry administration would be "culturally…

Gary Schmitt · Sep 22

Bullying Taiwan

IT HAS BECOME de rigueur for China to oppose Taiwan's status as a self-governing nation at every possible turn. As two events last week demonstrate, Beijing's determination to squeeze Taiwan continues unabated, with scant opposition.

Tim Lehmann · Sep 22

Nothing To Do With the Truth

YESTERDAY, John Kerry repeated what has become a standard Kerry-Edwards campaign talking point: Saddam's Iraq had "no ties to al Qaeda," or, as Kerry recently told Time, Saddam Hussein had "nothing to do with al Qaeda."

Daniel McKivergan · Sep 22

Lugar's Other Comments

OVER THE WEEKEND, comments made by Republican Senator Dick Lugar of Indiana concerning aspects of the Bush administration's post-Iraq policy received lots of media attention. But the senator has also commented on the Iraq speech John Kerry delivered yesterday before an audience at New York…

Daniel McKivergan · Sep 21

Red Ink in the Skies

BUSINESS IS BOOMING. Most airplanes are full, or almost so, including--so British Airways's staff tell me--the pricey first- and business-class cabins on most transatlantic flights. As September 11 recedes from memory, and as the business recovery takes hold, carriers are putting more buns on…

Irwin M. Stelzer · Sep 21

Storm Front

CHARLEY CAME IN AUGUST, smacking the Florida coast with high winds and torrential rain and a surge of water several stories high. He was followed soon after by Frances, who was about 500 miles across the waist, who tore through the tiny island of Grenada before setting her eye on the United States,…

Matthew Continetti · Sep 21

Diana Kerry Speaks Australian

IN COMMENTS to the Weekend Australian, Diana Kerry, the younger sister of the Democratic presidential candidate, has expressed concern for the safety of Australians facing an increased terrorism threat brought on by the U.S.-led intervention in Iraq. The Bali bombing and the more recent attack on…

Amanda Sokolski · Sep 20

For Kerry, It's Always Vietnam

IN THE MIDST of all the committee-produced and consultant-shaped verbiage of John Kerry's "major" speech on Iraq today, one paragraph stands out as being truly Kerry's own:

William Kristol · Sep 20

Who's Better in the Driver's Seat?

ECONOMIST FRIENDS who have served in government like to joke that after a newly arrived president has finished admiring the Oval Office, he starts hunting for the secret room containing the knobs that control the economy. It's always a fruitless search. Still, presidents are not completely…

Irwin M. Stelzer · Sep 20

A Not-So-Phony Coalition

LAST NOVEMBER, suicide bombers killed 19 Italians stationed at a military police barracks in Nasiriyah, southern Iraq. It was the largest single-incident loss of life for the Italian military since the Second World War, and the shock and pain that reverberated through the country was palpable.…

Gerard Baker · Sep 20

Embryo-centrism and Other Sins

AFTER MORE THAN TWO YEARS of complaining that President Bush's Council on Bioethics has been a reactionary, jaundiced, and unscientific influence upon American science policy, its critics have changed tack. The sneer du jour is that it has had no effective influence upon the administration.

Michael Cook · Sep 20

Neoparenting

AS NEW PARENTS, my wife and I want and need plenty of advice. From time immemorial, that advice came from elders--parents and grandparents and other wise souls who were presumed to know better because of their life experience. No longer. We parents of the new millennium know better than to look to…

John Podhoretz · Sep 20

One War, Many Fronts

AS AMERICAN POLITICIANS point fingers and question one another's qualifications for leading a war on terror, as Europeans and Americans hurl mutual recriminations about the war in Iraq, the terrorists have been acting. Radical Islamists have struck Spain, forcing a change of government there. They…

Frederick W. Kagan · Sep 20

Rather Flawed

LAST WEDNESDAY, CBS News's 60 Minutes II aired a report that strongly challenged George W. Bush's service in the National Guard. It's a story that has been explored dozens of times in the past five years. Two things in the 60 Minutes II story made it fresh--or, in newsroom parlance, gave it a peg.…

Stephen F. Hayes · Sep 20

Taking Flip-Flops Seriously

I said at the time I would have preferred if we had given diplomacy a greater opportunity, but I think it was the right decision to disarm Saddam Hussein. And when the president made the decision, I supported him, and I support the fact that we did disarm him. John F. Kerry, May 3, 2003 Those who…

Robert Kagan · Sep 20

The Grey Book

MIX EQUAL PARTS a vague Star Wars daydream ("Only you can save America, Luke") and a paranoid Matrix fantasy ("There is no America, Neo, only the System"). Add a dash of old-style political manifesto, a pinch of new-age mysticism, and just a touch of J.S. Mill's On Liberty, and you've got that part…

Harry Siegel · Sep 20

The Luck of the President

BETTER TO BE LUCKY than good. That's an old baseball saying that applies as well to President Bush's reelection campaign. First CBS News--then the entire mainstream media--plays up damaging documents about Bush's National Guard service. But within hours, thanks to bloggers and not to any effort by…

Fred Barnes · Sep 20

The Party of Europe

"I've met foreign leaders who can't go out and say this publicly, but boy, they look at you and say, 'You've got to win this, you've got to beat this guy, we need a new policy,' things like that." Senator John Kerry, March 6, 2004 "As the president has made very clear, there is a difference between…

Daniel Twining · Sep 20

The Road from Riyadh to Beslan

THREE ROADS led to the horror at Beslan in the Russian republic of North Ossetia, in which at least 330 people, most of them children, died: one road beginning in Grozny, the capital of neighboring Chechnya; one road beginning in Moscow, to the north; and one road beginning in Riyadh, the capital…

Stephen Schwartz · Sep 20

Waugh on Screen

EVELYN WAUGH thought movies vapid and dishonest, one of the evils of the modern age. In the Waughian universe, the film industry attracted self-promoters and hucksters, always at the ready to trade their own self worth for a bloated swell of bogus importance. Hollywood is the setting for the…

Gaby Wenig · Sep 20

From Good to Great

AS FAR BACK as I can remember, I always wondered why there was no remastered DVD of Goodfellas. It was bad enough knowing there exists a special edition of The Godfather Part III. And yet the only version available of Martin Scorsese's mob masterpiece was a disc so primitive you had to flip it over…

Victorino Matus · Sep 20

Ducks, Ferrets, and Arnold--Oh My!

BACK FROM HIS ORATORICAL tour de force at the Republican National Convention, Arnold Schwarzenegger gets to devote the remainder of September to business as usual in Sacramento.

Bill Whalen · Sep 17

Kerry's Flip-Flopping on Russia

IN REACTION to Russian President Vladimir Putin's announcement this week of plans to curtail democratic institutions in Russia and assert increased political control over the country from Moscow, Democratic presidential nominee Senator John Kerry criticized President Bush for having "taken his eye…

Vance Serchuk · Sep 16

Call in Congress

INSIDE THE BUNKER AT CBS, Dan Rather must be finally feeling some sympathy for Richard Nixon. Rather is caught in a cover-up begun during a presidential campaign, the cover-up is unraveling, and a baying pack of critics greets his every utterance with disdain, as mockery begins to replace analysis.…

Hugh Hewitt · Sep 16

No Terrorism in Iraq Before the War?

"There was no terrorism in Iraq before we went to war." --Stephanie Cutter, chief spokesman, John Kerry for President Los Angeles Times, September 9, 2004 IN THE LAST FEW DAYS, John Kerry's campaign has challenged Bush administration claims of an Iraq-al Qaeda connection. The effort has been…

Stephen F. Hayes · Sep 16

Wrong Choices

"Every time George Bush has had a choice, he has really chosen, I think, the wrong thing." --John Kerry, September 15, 2004 WHAT ABOUT some of John Kerry's foreign policy choices in the last two decades?

Daniel McKivergan · Sep 15

Another New Kerry Position on Iraq . . .

ON DON IMUS'S RADIO SHOW this morning, John Kerry suggested that he would not have gone to war with Iraq, knowing what we know now (no evident stocks of weapons of mass destruction): "Not under the current circumstances, not that I see. I voted on the basis of weapons of mass destruction," Kerry…

William Kristol · Sep 15

A Footnote toThe New Soldier

AFTER HIS 1971 appearance before the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, John Kerry had to publicly defend his testimony. He debated fellow Swift Boat veteran John O'Neill, a young pro-Nixon conservative and future author of the anti-Kerry bestseller Unfit for Command, most prominently on the Dick…

David Skinner · Sep 15

Kitty Litter

ON PAGE 266 of her new book The Family: The Real Story of the Bush Dynasty, Kitty Kelley writes, "[The president's] sister-in-law Sharon Bush alleged that [George W. Bush] has snorted cocaine with one of his brothers at Camp David during the time their father was President of the United States.…

Rachel DiCarlo · Sep 15

Powell's Darfur Declaration

LAST THURSDAY, Secretary of State Colin Powell finally called a spade a spade. Testifying before the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, he said the atrocities--including murder, rape, and village razing--committed in the remote Darfur region of western Sudan qualified as genocide.

Duncan Currie · Sep 15

Likely Bedfellows

Update 6:05 p.m.: Late Tuesday afternoon, NBC News and CBS News requested that that the Democratic National Committee pull the campaign video in question. The DNC, through a spokesman, says that the matter is under consideration.

Stephen F. Hayes · Sep 14

Watching the Media Watchdogs

Breaking their silence on the CBS forgeries, the Columbia Journalism Review's Campaign Desk finally mentioned the scandal yesterday afternoon. In a post titled Blog Report, CJR finally turned to the biggest media story in recent memory; they gave it five sentences:

Jonathan V. Last · Sep 14

Rather Bad

JUST IN TIME to brighten our Sunday, the Washington Post broke with precedent and ran a hilarious piece of satire on its op-ed page, all about the "end of network news." The crisis, it appears, is that the networks have gone too commercial and ceded coverage of the political conventions to . . .…

Noemie Emery · Sep 14

"So far, so good"

SECRETARY OF DEFENSE Donald Rumsfeld told an audience at the National Press Club last Friday afternoon that America must remain on the offensive and cannot be "faint-hearted" when it comes to the war on terrorism--a war he likened to the Cold War. He also spoke optimistically about the progress…

Erin Montgomery · Sep 14

The AP: At It Again

"FRANK JONES says he's angry about newly revealed memos that indicate President Bush got preferential treatment in the Air National Guard during the Vietnam War." So reads the lede of an AP story released on Saturday, September 11.

Katherine ManguWard · Sep 13

Kerry and the "Direct Link"

ON SUNDAY, the Kerry campaign put out a statement accusing the Bush administration of "misleading" the country in claiming a "direct link" between Saddam Hussein and the 9/11 attacks.

William Kristol · Sep 13

Kerry's North Korea Non-policy

YESTERDAY, John Kerry called the New York Times to blast the Bush administration's North Korea policy. As David Sanger wrote in today's front-page Times story, it is "highly unusual for Mr. Kerry to seek out a reporter on Sunday, when he had no public appearances scheduled, to attack Mr. Bush."

William Kristol · Sep 13

The Burden of Belief

CBS has left the flap over purported documents involving President Bush's record in the Texas Air National Guard in this posture: Who are you going to believe, CBS or your lyin' eyes?

Fred Barnes · Sep 13

Bush Takes Manhattan

THE PRESIDENTIAL RACE consists of two campaigns. One concerns who would be the better commander in chief in the war on terrorism. President Bush, bolstered by speech after speech at the Republican convention (including his own), is handily winning that race. The other, the campaign John Kerry…

Fred Barnes · Sep 13

Bush's Greatness

IT'S OBVIOUS not only that George W. Bush has already earned his Great President badge (which might even outrank the Silver Star) but that much of the opposition to Bush has a remarkable and very special quality; one might be tempted to call it "lunacy." But that's too easy. The "special quality"…

David Gelernter · Sep 13

Bush's Stealth Flat Tax

OF ALL THE policy recommendations in the president's acceptance speech last week, none got more applause than his promise to revamp our antiquated and antigrowth IRS tax code. But even a mild cynic has to wonder whether this call for a "simpler, fairer, pro-growth tax code" was just a flirtation…

Stephen Moore · Sep 13

Full Court Press

IT'S HARD TO IMAGINE how the Senate could become more partisan than it is today. But that's what Democrats vow will happen if Republicans attempt a rare parliamentary maneuver to break the stalemate over President Bush's judicial nominees.

Duncan Currie · Sep 13

I Can't Believe I Watched the Whole Thing

ACCORDING TO a monograph I read a while back, called "The Rise and Fall of the Televised Political Convention," television networks used to cover political conventions for 10 hours a day, sometimes more. Then they gave up, and you can't really blame them. The all-news cable channels, it was…

Andrew Ferguson · Sep 13

The Kerry Crackup

IN A WEEK dedicated to Republican speechifying about why John Kerry should not be the next president of the United States, the most persuasive words came from a Democrat. And I don't mean Zell Miller's invigorating speech on Wednesday.

Stephen F. Hayes · Sep 13

The Majority Party

Fortunately, we had a resolute president named Truman, who, with the American people, persevered, knowing that a new democracy at the center of Europe would lead to stability and peace. George W. Bush, at the Republican convention Those policies--containing communism, deterring attack by the Soviet…

William Kristol · Sep 13

The Standard Reader

Books in Brief My Name is Bill by Susan Cheever (Simon & Schuster, 306 pp., $24.00). Bill Wilson is the most influential American you've never heard of--unless you're a recovering alcoholic. Wilson, a near-hopeless drunk, founded Alcoholics Anonymous in 1935. The key to sobering up, he had learned,…

Unknown · Sep 13

Now They Want to Euthanize Children

FIRST, Dutch euthanasia advocates said that patient killing will be limited to the competent, terminally ill who ask for it. Then, when doctors began euthanizing patients who clearly were not terminally ill, sweat not, they soothed: medicalized killing will be limited to competent people with…

Wesley J. Smith · Sep 13

The Hoaxing of CBS

A NUMBER OF EXPERTS have now weighed in on the inauthenticity of the documents CBS breathlessly revealed on 60 Minutes earlier this week--documents purportedly typed by the deceased commander of George W. Bush's Texas Air National Guard unit in 1972 and 1973, but actually produced on a personal…

Richard Starr · Sep 10

Anatomy of a Murder

HAVE YOU ever wondered how Hollywood makes so many bad movies? If the movie-making process was random, then some small percentage of films every year would be good just by chance. Yet the product put out is so relentlessly bad that it defies probability: The people who make movies must be doing…

Jonathan V. Last · Sep 10

Is It a Hoax?

DOCUMENTS CITED Wednesday by 60 Minutes in a widely-publicized expose of George W. Bush's National Guard Service are very likely forgeries, according to several experts on document authenticity and typography. The documents--four memos from Killian to himself or his files written in 1972 and…

Stephen F. Hayes · Sep 9

"The Unmentionable Odor of Death"

The unmentionable odor of death Offends the September night -W.H. Auden, "September 1, 1939" AND SO IT DOES, once again. Three years ago, the terrorists attacked symbols of U.S. strength. Last week, they struck at the children of School No. 1 in Beslan. In between, the forces of barbarism, holding…

William Kristol · Sep 9

Oh Albert, Where Art Thou?

EVERY DAY, it becomes more and more obvious that a dreadful wrong has been done to Al Gore. No, not the outcome of the 2000 election, though that would have been gruesome for anyone. The election was a tie, each side had grounds to complain about one court or another, and each had reason to believe…

Noemie Emery · Sep 9

One Weekend in April, A Long Time Ago . . .

IN THE SPRING of 1985 Ronald Reagan struggled with a Democrat-dominated Congress for authority to ship aid to the Nicaraguan Contras fighting the spreading grip of the Sandinistas on their Central American country. There was quite a lot of heated rhetoric and over-the-top theater. The Sandinistas…

Hugh Hewitt · Sep 9

If John Kerry Were President . . .

SO MUCH for the much-promised Kerry foreign policy speech. In Cincinnati today, John Kerry basically repeated his stump speech, with no sustained discussion of Iraq, the war on terror, or foreign policy in general. An astonishingly weak performance. Is Kerry so wrapped around the axle on Iraq that…

William Kristol · Sep 8

The Fall Classic

CONVENTIONAL WISDOM has it that John Kerry's problems began with a convention that produced no bounce, followed by a Swift boat veterans offensive that tarnished the senator's warrior image.

Bill Whalen · Sep 8

Kerry vs. Kerry

JOHN KERRY said yesterday that Iraq was "the wrong war in the wrong place at the wrong time." Translation: We would be better off if Saddam Hussein were still in power.

William Kristol · Sep 7

He Made It There . . .

THE NEW YORK CITY CONVENTION was a smashing success. The Bush campaign and the White House should seize upon the convention's lesson and apply it to win this vital election. The lesson is obvious--the campaign is about President Bush and when we focus on making the case for his reelection, he sells…

Mike Murphy · Sep 7

The Wal-Martization of America

THROUGHOUT the start-and-stop growth that has characterized the American economy in the past year, all eyes have been on the American consumer. Accounting for about 70 percent of the U.S. economy, consumers have kept the American and, indeed, the world economies from slipping into a deep recession…

Irwin M. Stelzer · Sep 7

A Conspiracy Too Vast

THE MINUTE the ads of Swift Boat Veterans for Truth had begun to draw blood, the Democrats attacked them as a giant, malevolent plot. The same plot, drawn up by a diabolical genius of unsurpassed malice and cunning, that has been causing Democrats trouble for so many years now, always unwarranted,…

Noemie Emery · Sep 6

Fahrenheit 1971

We will not quickly join those who march on Veterans' Day waving small flags, calling to memory those thousands who died for the "greater glory of the United States." We will not accept the rhetoric. We will not readily join the American Legion and the Veterans of Foreign Wars--in fact, we will…

Mackubin Thomas Owens · Sep 6

John Kerry, in His Own Words

At the beginning of last week, the online magazine Salon.com asked a "roundtable of experts," on the eve of the Republican convention, What can President Bush do to win reelection in November?

William Kristol · Sep 6

John McCain Was Right

JOHN MCCAIN WARNED John Kerry, a fellow Vietnam vet, not to emphasize the Vietnam war in his presidential campaign. No good would come of it. It would only reopen old wounds. Kerry ignored McCain's advice. The Democratic convention made Kerry's Vietnam record the focus of his candidacy. To know the…

Fred Barnes · Sep 6

Kerry's Little Red Bookshelf

JOHN KERRY has written the introduction to Let America Be America Again, a new but very slim selection of verse by the famous black poet Langston Hughes. In the preface, Kerry insists he was "drawn to incorporate the words" of the title--taken from a poem Hughes wrote in the 1930s--into his…

Allan Ryskind · Sep 6

Khan Woman

A MAN HAS BEEN in the news lately, accused of dishonorable behavior in war, and Iam here today to defend him. Blood, after all, is thicker than water.

Katherine ManguWard · Sep 6

Less Respect, More Success

ONE OF JOHN F. KERRY'S most damning accusations against President Bush is that he has made America a global pariah, thereby undercutting the international cooperation we need to win the war on terrorism. Kerry pledges to restore "America's respect and leadership so we don't have to go it alone in…

Max Boot · Sep 6

Notes from the Undergrad

IN 1965, JOHN KERRY, a junior at Yale and the newly appointed head of the Yale Political Union, was invited to give a speech at Choate, the tony prep school known mainly for its famous alumnus John F. Kennedy. Like Yale, Choate is in Connecticut, so Kerry didn't have to travel far. He went with his…

Matthew Continetti · Sep 6

The Not-So-Swift Mainstream Media

DURING THE AUGUST 19 edition of PBS's NewsHour, Tom Oliphant unspooled. "The standard of clear and convincing evidence--and it's easy when you leave out the exculpatory stuff--is what keeps this story in the tabloids," the Boston Globe columnist sputtered, "because it does not meet basic…

Jonathan V. Last · Sep 6

The Vanity of Vanity

"STARS WILL NOT play weak and they will not play blemished," William Goldman wrote in his seminal 1983 book, Adventures in the Screen Trade. "Try asking a major star to play a real Mafia head, a man who makes his living off whores and child pornography, heroin and blood; sorry folks, those parts go…

John Podhoretz · Sep 6

The Way It Wasn't

PART FICTION, part historical speculation, the publishing genre known as "alternate history" is a literary chimera--a seeming anomaly that is perfectly in sync with its time. Popularized by the Edwardians, alternate history pottered along for decades, mostly as a literary curiosity, before roaring…

Gregory Feeley · Sep 6

The Kerry Record

BEHIND THE STARTLING FLIP-FLOPS, beneath the gauzy rhetoric, what does John Kerry really think about foreign and defense policy? Ranging from his 1971 testimony on Vietnam to his current statements on Iraq and the war on terror, there's a lot to be said. But one good place to start, of course, is…

Daniel McKivergan · Sep 3

Bush's Economic Advantage

THERE IS AN OLD POLITICAL SAYING: "It is better to be lucky than good." This week, President Bush was both: He gave a well-received acceptance speech to the Republican convention, and now he gets a jobs report that suggests his economic recovery program is working.

Irwin M. Stelzer · Sep 3

Hard to Please

THE SPEAKERS at the GOP convention this week agree on two things: that the war on terror trumps all other issues, and that President Bush would wage a stronger, more determined war than John Kerry.

Rachel DiCarlo · Sep 2

Bush's Big Night

PRESIDENT BUSH has reason to be delighted, though not giddy, as he prepares for his acceptance speech to the Republican convention tonight. He's already gotten to the point in the campaign against John Kerry where he figured to be after the convention. Several weeks ago, he was a few points down.…

Fred Barnes · Sep 2

The End of the Affair

IT'S OVER. The love affair of the left with John McCain is now ending, as these things do so often, in tears. Of course, liberals' hearts have been broken before, usually as the result of some cherished illusion that a maverick Republican, who seems to them "better," will blow the whistle on the…

Noemie Emery · Sep 2

They're No Satiric Geniuses

IF YOU'RE going to be in New York, you ought to see a show. There's the usual Broadway fare, such as 42nd Street and The Lion King--assuming the talent shows up (the New York Post last week reported that anti-Bush actors were talking of calling in sick to avoid performing for Republicans). There's…

Jonathan V. Last · Sep 2

It Was This Big . . .

SENATOR JOHN KERRY told veterans at the American Legion convention in Nashville today that America is engaged in a "global war on terror against an enemy unlike any we have known before." But last January he called the threat from this same enemy an "exaggeration."

Daniel McKivergan · Sep 1

John Edwards: Disrespecting Our Allies

ON MONDAY, speaking in Wilmington, North Carolina, Democratic vice presidential candidate John Edwards gave a major foreign policy address that insulted America's allies in the war on terror, and suggested giving France and Germany a virtual veto over American security policy.

Gary Schmitt · Sep 1

No Bargain

IN AN INTERVIEW with the Washington Post published yesterday, Democratic vice-presidential nominee John Edwards promised that a Kerry administration would offer a "grand bargain" to the totalitarian theocracy in Iran. This "grand bargain" would allow the Islamic state to keep its nuclear power…

Thomas Donnelly · Sep 1

Loving Laura

THE TALK OF THE GARDEN last night was Arnold Schwarzenegger's exuberant tribute to the American freedom that first drew him to fame and fortune in California. Every other pundit compared his oratory to Ronald Reagan's. Many Republicans criticized the organizers for failing to end the evening on…

Christopher Caldwell · Sep 1

Daschled Dreams

As reporters focus on upcoming speeches from Vice President Dick Cheney and President George W. Bush, many delegates in New York City are buzzing about a Senate race that could mean the end of Tom Daschle's political career. Daschle is facing John Thune, a well-spoken former member of the House,…

Stephen F. Hayes · Sep 1

How to Win Ohio

THE WEEK the mayor of Youngstown, Ohio, had dinner at the White House, his party back home did something that stuck in Mayor McKelvey's craw. It named Jerry Springer Ohio Democrat of the Year for 2004.

Claudia Winkler · Sep 1

The Convention's Silver Lining

ACTOR RON SILVER has played some amazing roles. He was boxing trainer Angelo Dundee in the movie Ali. He was defense lawyer Alan Dershowitz in Reversal of Fortune. And he played Secretary of State Henry Kissinger in Kissinger and Nixon, a TV film about the final days of the Vietnam war. At the…

Fred Barnes · Sep 1

The Veep, Big Time

IN A PROFILE that aired over the first two mornings of the Republican National Convention, ABC News reporter Claire Shipman asked Vice President Dick Cheney about his alleged distaste for retail politicking. Shipman read a comment from a reporter who covered Cheney. The vice president, this…

Stephen F. Hayes · Sep 1